theStick vs.

theStick vs. 18Birdies for Golf Betting

3 min read · by theStick

18Birdies is, first and foremost, a GPS and scorecard app — green-to-pin distances, shot tracking, stats over time — and it does that job well, which is exactly why so many golfers already have it on their phone. Betting shows up as a feature inside that app, not the reason it exists. That ordering matters: a few built-in wager types are a genuinely nice bonus on top of a GPS app people were already using anyway, but it's a different thing from a product built specifically to run and settle real group money.

What 18Birdies is genuinely good at

Best-in-class GPS and shot tracking. Distances, hazards, club stats — this is the actual core of the product, and it's polished.

Already installed. A huge number of golfers already have it for the rangefinder alone, so there's no "getting the group to download something new" friction if everyone's already on it.

Solo stats over time. Fairways, greens, putts, strokes gained — a real personal-improvement tool independent of any group game.

Lightweight wager types built in. Nassau, skins, and a few side bets are there if a group wants to flip them on for a casual round.

Where it comes up short for real group betting

The betting features are simplified, not comprehensive. 18Birdies covers a handful of the most common bet types reasonably well, but it isn't trying to be a full betting engine — no wolf, no banker, no snake, no dots, no the dozens of side-game formats real groups actually run across a season. The moment your group's "the usual games" list is longer than nassau and skins, there's nowhere to go.

Handicap-aware stroke allocation isn't the product's focus. A GPS/stats app's handicap number exists mostly to contextualize a round, not to drive hole-by-hole stroke allocation across several simultaneous betting games with different rules for who gets a stroke where. It's a different level of precision than a product built around settling real money needs.

No real spectator experience. There's no live-watch link for a friend, spouse, or the guy who couldn't make the round to follow along in real time — the app is built for the person playing, not for the people around them who want to check in from the clubhouse or from home.

No season-long structure. A recurring group — a weekly game, a league, a multi-week club series — has nothing here to tie rounds together: no standings, no recurring roster, no running ledger of who's up for the year. Every round is its own island.

Ads and a subscription paywall sit between you and the features you actually want. As a free GPS app supported by ads and a premium tier, the core betting/scoring flow can feel like it's competing for space with the app's actual business model, rather than being the whole point of opening it.

The fair take

If you already have 18Birdies open every round for the rangefinder, and your group runs a simple nassau or skins game, using its built-in wager toggle costs nothing extra — it's already there. That's a real, legitimate use case, and there's no reason to add a second app just for that.

Where it stops being enough is the moment your group runs more than the basics, wants real people to actually apply strokes correctly across several games at once, wants a friend or family member to watch live, or wants any season-long structure to how a recurring group's results add up. That's a purpose-built betting product's job, not a GPS app's side feature — which is the specific gap theStick is built to fill.

See it on

Game rules mentioned in this article

Skins Nassau Wolf

More comparisons

theStick vs. Golf Genius: One App for the Weekly Game and the Real Tournament theStick vs. a Spreadsheet for Golf Betting theStick vs. Paper Scorecards and Venmo theStick vs. TheGrint for Golf Betting